ERROR, MD5 signature mismatch

[craig62]

http://www.thetradersden.org/forums/...ad.php?t=42862 is the torrent in question.

flac 1.1.3, Copyright (C) 2000,2001,2002,2003,2004,2005,2006 Josh Coalson
flac comes with ABSOLUTELY NO WARRANTY. This is free software, and you are
welcome to redistribute it under certain conditions. Type `flac' for details.

02 - Honky Tonk Women [Live].FLAC: ERROR, MD5 signature mismatch

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Same error message for all 16 FLAC files.

The files will decode if the "Decode through errors" option on TLH or FLAC Frontend is enabled.

st5 for track 2 FLAC and WAV:
dd727c7efa9d3d960aae5e1816936ac2 [shntool] 02 - Honky Tonk Women [Live].FLAC
dd727c7efa9d3d960aae5e1816936ac2 [shntool] 02 - Honky Tonk Women [Live].wav

FFP for track 2:
02 - Honky Tonk Women [Live].FLAC:d0db120f6f0550bd7d9b2d10d9657319


FFP included in torrent:

01 - Let It Rock [Live].FLAC:4745522c207469746c6520544558542c
02 - Honky Tonk Women [Live].FLAC:d0db120f6f0550bd7d9b2d10d9657319
03 - Miss You [Live].FLAC:dd727c7efa9d3d960aae5e1816936ac2
04 - Respectable [Live].FLAC:87dc3526d83fd1f2980def5a0faf0a6c
05 - Just My Imagination [Live].FLAC:6e8ecaa586670887daaea234e1adb20c
06 - Shattered [Live].FLAC:c3f77d16084ea49a60bb6165fd68c02f
07 - Far Away Eyes [Live].FLAC:66465e1d56beaeb7f74afe0fe65717a5
08 - Sweet Little Sixteen [Live].FLAC:b97c78a70786b276bee89a60c012a267
09 - Lies [Live].FLAC:1f0c17cc71a27c8d6e620ca89b13fb12
10 - Love In Vain [Live].FLAC:b7e36ccd0d27da5eaaf5fb1c21395b88
11 - Tumbling Dice [Live].FLAC:8d4e7ec5c0859821f08ce8bd64650eca
12 - When The Whip Comes Down [Live].FLAC:73be174ed6550e39c4832530766e61a0
13 - Brown Sugar [Live].FLAC:5eea2461759465c913cc8182c17aa662
14 - Beast Of Burden [Live].FLAC:7da73abd29485c530b286651c63a70b5
15 - Hound Dog [Live].FLAC:5b680f3567821d1484722a6810a8e68f
16 - Jumpin' Jack Flash [Live].FLAC:14a8765aaf8e1637ba81925b25523e8b


st5 generated by TLH:

d0db120f6f0550bd7d9b2d10d9657319 [shntool] 01 - Let It Rock [Live].FLAC
dd727c7efa9d3d960aae5e1816936ac2 [shntool] 02 - Honky Tonk Women [Live].FLAC
87dc3526d83fd1f2980def5a0faf0a6c [shntool] 03 - Miss You [Live].FLAC
6e8ecaa586670887daaea234e1adb20c [shntool] 04 - Respectable [Live].FLAC
c3f77d16084ea49a60bb6165fd68c02f [shntool] 05 - Just My Imagination [Live].FLAC
66465e1d56beaeb7f74afe0fe65717a5 [shntool] 06 - Shattered [Live].FLAC
b97c78a70786b276bee89a60c012a267 [shntool] 07 - Far Away Eyes [Live].FLAC
1f0c17cc71a27c8d6e620ca89b13fb12 [shntool] 08 - Sweet Little Sixteen [Live].FLAC
b7e36ccd0d27da5eaaf5fb1c21395b88 [shntool] 09 - Lies [Live].FLAC
8d4e7ec5c0859821f08ce8bd64650eca [shntool] 10 - Love In Vain [Live].FLAC
73be174ed6550e39c4832530766e61a0 [shntool] 11 - Tumbling Dice [Live].FLAC
5eea2461759465c913cc8182c17aa662 [shntool] 12 - When The Whip Comes Down [Live].FLAC
7da73abd29485c530b286651c63a70b5 [shntool] 13 - Brown Sugar [Live].FLAC
5b680f3567821d1484722a6810a8e68f [shntool] 14 - Beast Of Burden [Live].FLAC
14a8765aaf8e1637ba81925b25523e8b [shntool] 15 - Hound Dog [Live].FLAC
c7152970f26d5499701ade25b4cd2660 [shntool] 16 - Jumpin' Jack Flash [Live].FLAC


Note that the st5 checksum string for track 1 is the same as the FFP checksum for track 2, the st5 checksum string for track 2 is the same as the FFP checksum for track 3, the st5 checksum string for track 3 is the same as the FFP checksum for track 4, etc.

The FFP checksum string for track 1 is not found in the st5 checksums, and the st5 checksum for track 16 is not found in the FFP checksums. All of the other checksum strings are found in both the FFP and st5, but none of them match up as far as the tracks go.

I've seen this happen in three different torrents before this one, and each time it was a Winamp rip/encode. I've never seen FLAC Frontend name files with the ".FLAC" (caps) extension, but I have seen it with Winamp: http://www.thetradersden.org/forums/...ad.php?t=42488

Also see http://www.thetradersden.org/forums/...ad.php?t=42567

[U2Lynne]

I pulled the show in question and I've PMed the seeder about this. It seems to have happened a couple of times with shows he has seeded so it would be nice to get to the bottom of this. Thanks Craig.